Ticci Toby x Reader Bitter-Sweet Candy Shop Part3

I skipped happily behind boss as he carries ___’s passed out body back to the mansion. Even with her unconscious she’s still really pretty! I felt my cheeks flush as I smile widely. Hoodie and Masky were a few steps behind but that’s ok! I like being in front.
    Normal POV:
I quickly open my eyes feeling the sudden rush of alarm, surging through all of my body. I take a few swift breaths before calming back down. I then slowly shut my eyes again to go back to sleep.
    “H-Hey! I saw your eyes o-open!” I hear a familiar voice say to me. I open my eyes again then look over to my left where his voice came from. I stare in awe for a few moments. The male before me had brown hair, pale, white-ish skin, gray eyes, and a slim physique.
    “Wait, you’re the kid that goes to my math class. You never talk to anyone. But wait you’re that Toby kid too….” I say sitting up to get a better look.
    “Y-yeah! That’s m-me!” He grins widely, showing off his nice teeth. “How are y-you feeling ___?” I slowly look around the room before slouching forward.
    “I don’t know….” He just continues to smile as he scoots a little closer in his chair. It was like he was waiting for something. “S-so um….Where am I?”
    “Slender’s mansion!” He answers very quickly. I furrow my brows confused.
“What?” Toby stands then walks over to a little portrait on the wall that shows a tall, faceless figure standing among the trees.
    “This is Slender! He’s our boss!” He giggles happily then sits next to me on the queen sized bed.
“Our?” Toby became very quiet all of a sudden which kind of freaked me out. “T-Toby?”
    “Don’t go near the others!” His voice was very angry and demanding out of nowhere. I jump a little hearing him growl as he stared off into space.
    “W-Why?”
“Because they might try to steal you away from me!!” My face became red. What is up with this guy? After a moment he loses his straightness and dipped his head. “Hey a-are you hungry? I can make some waffles for us!” He smiles widely again, taking hold of my hand. I sweat drop but agree and follow him out of the room we were in. I took one long look around the hallway with amazement. The ceiling was the tallest I’d ever seen! There were pretty, little chandeliers hanging from up high, the doors where super tall too! The walls where a deep red along with the carpet, and the accent color was a very dark brown. All in all it looked like a vampire’s castle. But it was still rather breath taking. I follow Toby all the way down to a large, fancy kitchen, where he went over to the stove to cook. “This p-place is pretty g-great isn’t it?” I shrug then nod.
    “Very fancy and unusual….” He giggled then started pouring the premade mix into the waffle press. The warm smell of their sweet bread like scent filled the air and I took it in with a deep breath. “Smells awesome.” I say and he agrees quickly. Once there was a huge stack on his and about three on mine, he came over with the syrup and sat down. After he pours the most of the bottle on his waffles he hands it to me. “So…..uh…..When can I….um…..go home?” Toby stops eating his waffles and looks at me.
    “Y-You want to l-leave? B-Bu you just got h-here! L-let’s have s-some fun first! Do you like swings? How about video games?” He smiles trying to change the subject.
    “Toby…..”
“NO!” He slammed his fist down, practically becoming someone else entirely. He stared at me before grabbing my arm and pulling me back to the room he took me from and threw me back in.
    “Tob-”
“NO! YOU’RE THE ONLY ONE WHO’S NICE TO ME! ALL THESE OTHERS AND NOT A SINGLE ONE WILL SMILE AT ME!” I blink with wide eyes as he yells then slams the door loudly. I try to make since of what happened but come up blank.
    Soon I found myself searching around the room only to find a little laptop. I turn it on and see it has no password. I open the search tab and look up Toby’s story.
    “I understand.” I mumble and close the window and sit back. “Toby? Please come back.” I say out and within a few moments Toby opened the door and skipped in.
    “Hi ___! How are y-you feeling? C-can we go s-swing now?” I sadly smile and nod. Toby lead me outside and to a small swing set with two seats and claims one. He waits for me so I sit next to him and he starts going. I kick the ground lightly not wanting to go high and stare off at the large building we came out of. “___?” I look over as Toby went back and forth and nod. “Do you know why I want to help you?” I shake my head.
    “No why?” He stopped himself and looked at me.
“Because you were having a hard time. And I didn’t want you to do something silly.” I stare at him, confused with what he meant. “My boss can see bits of the future, and he saw you trying to raise money but someone kidnapped you and hurt you badly.” I frown my brows still trying to understand his words.
    “Well couldn’t you have been there to stop him?” He shook his head.
“I didn’t wanna risk not making it in time. I thought that maybe if I interfered with your life I could save you from that…..I had already watched you long enough to the point I became attached to you. Even though you don’t know me and probably don’t like me. I just wanted to keep you safe.” I blush then smiled a little.
    “Thank you Toby.” He grins widely and stands from the swing.
“Y-You’re welcome!” I then notice why I was a little confused. He didn’t stutter on a single word!
    Hours passed and Toby and I had a great time. But once night began to fall, I knew I needed to get home.
    “Toby…..Can you take me home?” He looked up from what he was doing and stared for a while at me. “I’ll come with you back here tomorrow if you let me go home right now.” He jumped to his feet and pulled me into his arms.
    “Ok! Let’s go!” He giggled then had me get onto his back. Once I was he starting running out of the forest towards an opening. I didn’t recognize where we were. Like we were in a completely different town. But after a while I started seeing streets I knew and calmed down a little. “W-We’re here _-__!” I smile and get down off his back.
    “Thank you Toby. You can come and get me tomorrow afternoon. And we can spend the whole time together.” He nodded then removed his mouth guard.
    “I-I will c-come as s-soon as I c-can!” And with that he pecked my lips and ran off. I felt my face turn red but smile even more as I watch him disappear. What a strange guy.
    I turn back to my house and see that everyone is still asleep. How long where we gone? I think then glance at my phone. It’s only four in the morning. I thought we were there for at least a few hours! I shake my head then climb up and through my window. I lay on the floor after pulling myself in and rest for a moment or two, but stand when I hear unfamiliar voices. One sounding giggly, and the other sounding slightly raspier. I creep over to the door and listen closely.
    “I swear there were at least two people living here.” One says.
“Well I don’t see anyone at all heh heh heh.” The gigging voice says. I carefully creak open the door but of course stealthy isn’t my strong suit, I fall out of the room like a baby foul on ice. I look up at the two in the hall and see a black and white clown, and a guy clad in black and white as well. But I knew too well about Jeff. I knew that was him standing in front of me.
    “Told you.” He says smugly.
“Ah haha but that’s only one there Jeff~! Where’s the second?” I stare as they start to argue and carefully inch away to downstairs. Which as easier than I thought it’d be. I scurry over to the living room and pull out my cell, seeing a few texts from Lucy. ‘Be home late, went with Brandon, omg gonna get cute new dress….’ Was send about thirty minutes ago. At least I know she’s safe.
    “Hey! Where’d she go?”
“Hahaha! Good job you lost her~”
    “Shut up!” I awkwardly stare in the direction they were in and shake my head. Not as scary as I thought they’d be….I head over to the front door and open it.
    “Found her.” I screech seeing someone else standing outside the door. Some guy in a blue mask stands tall, looking down at me. “Why do we want her?” He looks up where the others are and shrugs to them. I take this chance while he’s not looking and try to get by but he grabs my shoulder and I yelp. “It’s not like I’m just gonna stop paying attention.” He says in a bored tone. I chuckle shyly and step back.
    “Hehehe! So~ Now that we have her, what do we do?” The clown says.
“Don’t know. Boss just said to watch her.” Jeff mumbles.
    “Hehehehe!! How BORING~! Let’s take her to the carnival! Or maybe to that little candy store down the street! Hehe! Hoaha!”
    “Someone broke in didn’t you here. I work there. Well….WORKED there…..”
“Oh, who’d break in?? It’s just a cute little store for kids~! Hahaha!”
    “That’s what I’ve been trying to find out…..There’s this guy who’s been wanting to take the place from us for a while to turn it into a liquor store…..but he’s too big of a wimp to try anything…..” The clown placed one of his long claw like fingers on his chin and tapped it a few times off in thought.
    “Well~ we could help you ‘find’ him~hehehee~” I shake my head.
“There’s no use. Even if we find him, he’s got enough money to get himself out of jail. AND take whatever’s left of the shop.” The British clown looked at the others and they shrugged.
    “But dead people can’t take things from people~” I gulp and back up a small bit.
“I don’t think killing him will solve things either…..we still wouldn’t have enough to keep the shop going…..”
    “How much do you need twerp?” I frown at Jeff then sign.
“Fifteen thousand.” The smirk on the clown’s face fade and he blinks.
    “That’s a lot….” I roll my eyes with a curt nod. “Oh also, how rude of us. I am Laughing Jack~ this is Jeff, and that’s Eyeless Jack. Pleased to meet you….”
    “___. Nice to meet you. Thanks for not killing me right away. And two Jacks huh? Are you both like…..wild cards? Haha.”
    “Ah I see what you did there.” I turn and face E.J and snicker.
“Did you really?” I then become still and just stares. “Uh….sorry….”
    “Well this just turned into a party of bad puns. Grab her. Let’s take her to the Boss.” Jeff says.
“At the mansion??? But I was just there! I wanna go to bed….” I complain, and he tilts his head.
    “You’ve already been there? What?”
“Yeah- your….BOSS snatched me out of my bed and I woke up in a room with Toby watching over me.”
    “Toby???” They all say. I nod and L.J laughs.
“No wonder he asked us to watch you~ Hehehe….He knew that moron would take a pretty girl like you anywhere you wanted to go! HA!” I blush a little at the clown as he giggles to himself. Jeff lets out an angry breathe then sits on my couch kicking his feet up onto the coffee table.
    “Hey-”
“Don’t complain or I’ll slice you into bits. My wife is having a child soon, so I’d like to take a little break.”++ I soften my face a little.
    “Congratulations…..” I smile and he shrugs. “Is it going to be a boy or a girl?”
“Don’t know. She wants it to be a ‘surprise.’” I giggle. How exciting!
    “But why a break? Aren’t you happy?”
“UGH stop asking questions. Yes I’m happy. I’m thrilled. But it’s a lot of work staying up all night to be there just in case she goes into labor. It’s a really big deal. So let me take a damn break.” I sigh and nod.
    “Ok. But honestly I don’t think we need three people to watch over me. You go back and be with her. I’m sure you don’t wanna miss that moment you’ll never get to see again.” He thinks for a moment then heads out one of the windows. I laugh and look back at the others and they chuckle.
    “That was cool of you. She’s a nice lady but she’s a bit snappier now that she could go into labor any day.” E.J mentions and I continue to smile widely.
    “Just being me~” After a few moments of silences the front door busts open and Toby is starting there panting.
    “___! I h-heard B-Boss sent people to c-ca-capture you so I came a-as fast as I could! Are you o-ok?” I furrow my brows seeing as he could’ve been way late if they had decided to kill me.
    “Just fine thanks.” I sweat drop and shrug. After a few awkward moments, I hear Lucy’s voice.
“Why’s the front door open-” She blinks at the people standing in the room then looks at me. I wave curtly to her and she continues to stare at me. I roll my eyes and we all grow silent.
    After a good five minutes of quiet, I explain everything to Lucy. She seemed oddly fine with everything so we got the others to leave so we could go to bed.
    The next morning I awoke to the sound of knocking, so I kicked my sheets off and hurried down the stairs half asleep. I open the door to find a girl with short black, blue, and purple hair, wearing a Gorillaz tshirt, with the words ‘That’s what Murdoc said’ on it, standing on the other side. I excitedly snap out of slumber and hug her.
    “SASHA!!” I squeal and she laughs.
“___! It’s been too long!” I nod letting go and stepping back so she could come in. “What’ve you been up to? I mean, sleeping I’d guess, seeing as you’re still in your Pjs.” I sheepishly look down and nod. “Well, it might be one in the afternoon but I don’t judge.” I chuckle then let her in and start to make breakfast.

To Be Continued.
I do not own Creepypasta/Proxies.
I do not own Ticci Toby.
Thanks for reading~ ^^